I accept homework as a necessary evil; but, I find busywork for the sake of having homework to be cruel and counter-productive. What if not doing homework was better for your kids? Do you see the connection? Heather — I am so proud of you!! What is “meaningful” homework? You may be surprised to learn that research supports this. Second, i agree that there is too much homework in elementary that is not truly meaningful practice.

They encourage reading every night at home. A comprehensive analysis of different research studies on homework concluded that homework has no academic benefit to children in elementary school. If the parents of the children in your classroom aren’t interested in supporting their learning, that is a shame, but ultimately, it’s up to individuals to make the right choices for themselves. I am a middle and upper school teacher at a private school. It doesn’t benefit her. If we want students to improve memory, focus, creative thinking, test performance and even school behavior, the answer is not more homework, the answer is more sleep.

Third grade home work has parents talk about behaviors and learning how to interact with other kids, once a week.

Here’s why I said no to homework for my elementary-aged kids |

Most homework is just checked in and sometimes not even that. Hope that answers your question. These studies were done by Dr.


heather shumaker homework

Even in preschool and kindergarten. Keith excelled in the new school. Of course his math teacher would say he needed to do the homework for practice. And my childs class is on there third teacher. Complicated and overwhelming don’t even begin to describe it. We also learned about USB codes and what they stand for. There are several good books presenting in-depth research against homework: I enjoy taking the time each night to help my children with their homework.

heather shumaker homework

We solved the homework problem by pulling him and his sister out of school and are now homeschooling shumakre older two, with two younger kids just beginning one preschool and one in kindergarten – public school. I give little homework and I’m always asked to assign more from parents.

Why not branch out and start a paid home-school co-op? Homework starts in preschool in many cases, and it only goes up from there.

Clash of Authorities: Discovering a Sane Path Out of Homework

Quite a bit as she is supposed to keep up with kids who have already been able to read before even starting pre-school. My son is in third grade and homework has always shjmaker optional, and he has always opted out.

heather shumaker homework

There is plenty of “work” at home. Parents need to play more too!

In that case, I hope both parent and child are willing to accept the lower grade that may result from a failure to turn in homework. I agree with this concept completely. Parents often assume the role of Shumakef Patrol Cop.


You can’t dictate TRUE learning. Only 20 students “max” per class vs. Hooray for teachers who are willing to listen shukaker an open heart! Keith was tested with an IQ of There is another way. As a child I spent my time outside riding my bike, climbing trees and playing pretend. I don’t think a college application will get much attention if the SAT scores are blank because the parent didn’t believe in that.

This isn’t an education system run by educators, it’s an education system run by politicians. We know this, but still we tend to act as Homework Enforcers. In a nutshell, her kids have [ The homework seriously is not that extensive in elementary school and homeowrk the parents take the time to make it a fun and positive time together there is still plenty of time for all the other stuff mentioned too. My oldest is in college on a full mathematics scholarship.